Headline and value proposition
Ask whether a new visitor would know who the page is for and what to do next. Notes like “headline feels generic” are fine if the client also says what audience or outcome feels missing.
Pin comments directly on the headline block in a screenshot so “the top” does not mean three different things.
Primary call to action
Check visibility, label clarity, and whether the CTA matches the page goal. “Book a demo” and “Contact us” signal different journeys—call out mismatches early.
Separate “I want a bigger button” from “I want more people to start a trial.” The second note is the one that should drive design decisions.
Layout and hierarchy
Review whether the main story reads in a sensible order on desktop and mobile. Crowding, weak section breaks, and buried social proof are common themes—one annotation per issue keeps tracking simple.
Save pixel-level colour debates for a later round if structure is still open.
Trust, mobile, and sign-off
Scan for testimonials, logos, policy links, and anything legally sensitive. On mobile, check whether the hero, CTA, and nav remain usable without horizontal scrolling.
When the checklist is complete, ask for explicit approval on the screenshot. QuillPin keeps that conversation on the image instead of scattered across email threads.